To make a simple, straightforward iced coffee Old Fashioned, combine cold brew, rye whiskey, and a dash of orange bitters. We recommend serving this one over a single large ice cube. It’s the ideal type of ice for any whiskey-based cocktail or enjoying whiskey plain on the rocks (or, rather, “rock” singular). It’s a fresh take on a familiar classic, but it’s also the foundation of other, more inventive coffee-infused Old Fashioned creations … if you dare.
The Rusty Nail is a variation on the Old Fashioned cocktail that mixes Scotch whiskey with Drambuie, a golden-colored liqueur made with honey, herbs, and spices. Its sweet, complex flavor profile would make it an excellent pair with iced coffee and a little Scotch for a killer digestif.
For foodies with an especially powerful sweet tooth, try whipping up this dessert version of a coffee Old Fashioned. Just combine chilled espresso, bourbon or whiskey, orange bitters, and a hint of chocolate with crème de cacao. For a richer flavor, you could even use a peanut butter whiskey. With this version, it might be wise to add all the ingredients to a shaker and dry shake. This is typically a no-no for an Old Fashioned, but this is certainly not the average list of ingredients, and it could use a helping hand to thoroughly incorporate.